Home / Investing / S&P 500 a tale of two indexes as mega-caps’ dominance skews performance: Neuberger Berman

S&P 500 a tale of two indexes as mega-caps’ dominance skews performance: Neuberger Berman

The benchmark S&P 500 index is characterised by "narrow, concentrated leadership" by a handful of mega-caps, leading to the "optical illusion" of outsized performance by US equities, says private investment manager Neuberger Berman.
Investing

Despite all the concerns facing the US economy – the fragility of regional banks, the debt ceiling and sticky inflation among them – its equity market, in particular the benchmark S&P 500, has seemingly proved largely resilient.

That is, until you pull back the curtain.

Do that, says Neuberger Berman president and chief investment officer for equities, Joseph V. Amato, and you’ll see the “optical illusion” filtering out broad underperformance in the top 500 companies across the US.

  • “Has the S&P 500 index really been resilient this year?” the respected economist asked in a recent post. “Or is it more like two very different indices, one that has performed very well and one not so well?”

    The optical illusion Amato refers to results from a bifurcation in the index that separates companies with outsized market share from the rest.

    “The first of those indices includes just seven ‘mega-cap’ companies that have built global dominance in their respective industries: Meta, Apple, Amazon, Alphabet, NVIDIA, Microsoft and Tesla. Let’s call it the FAANG+ Index. Each company’s market capitalization is over half a trillion dollars,” Amato says.

    “Those seven companies account for a quarter of the market capitalization of the S&P 500 and 90 per cent of its 8 per cent return year-to-date – a narrowness of leadership that has not been seen for decades. This is quite unique to the U.S. large-cap market.

    “Then there is the rest of the index.”

    The reason this matters, he explains, is that investors typically think about valuations and index earnings in aggregate. That is, they tend to look at the total performance of the S&P 500 and apportion that performance across the entire index instead of conducting a more nuanced assessment.

    “The current consensus S&P 500 index earnings estimate for calendar year 2023 is $220 per share, which gives a forward price-to-earnings multiple of 19 times,” he says.

    “In reality, however, most of the S&P 500 index is trading not at 19 times 2023 earnings, but 17 times, which is closer to the long-run average. The aggregate number is distorted by the fact that our FAANG+ Index is trading on a multiple of almost 30 times earnings.”

    The upshot, Amato says, is that Neuberger Berman is slightly more wary of the US stock market.

    “Make no mistake: we are cautious,” he said. “We think inflation will be stickier than consensus estimates, that rates will stay higher for longer, and that earnings have further to decline as those high rates and tight financial conditions start to bite. Narrow, concentrated leadership in the stock market has historically been a negative leading indicator, and the fact that it comes from such an extremely small and high-quality group of stocks on this occasion only reinforces our caution.

    “That said, recognizing the bifurcation of the index can help us appreciate that it is not as it appears on the surface – which might explain why market participants appear less concerned that one might expect.”




    Print Article

    Related
    Dividend yield in the hand worth keeping for banks’ shareholder army

    Self-funded retirees understand the capital risk in holding the ‘big four’. It’s one they’re prepared to take knowing their effective grossed-up yields are much higher than the nominal figure.

    James Dunn | 4th Dec 2024 | More
    Tough choice for self-funded retirees – term deposits or private credit

    With many economists expecting the Reserve Bank to start cutting interest rates in early 2025, returns on term deposits could feel the pinch. Private credit is an alternative, but those pursuing this investment option will need to do their homework – thoroughly.

    Nicholas Way | 6th Nov 2024 | More
    Some golden rules to help investors pick a mining gem

    Gold stocks have long appealed to market aficionados, and there’s no shortage of choice with 185 miners publicly listed. To assess what’s value, and what’s not, there are some key metrics to help sort the wheat from the chaff.

    Nicholas Way | 6th Nov 2024 | More
    Popular